Teach Don’t Preach – Please join the discussion on religion in Irish schools

If you would like to discuss any of these ideas further, you can do so on the Atheist Ireland discussion forum.

You don’t have to be a member of Atheist Ireland to join the discussion forum. It’s a place where you can ask questions and share ideas.

Our discussion forum is moderated in order to protect from offensive behaviour. You question or answer may not appear immediately. Please bear with us in any delays – we are all volunteers and have no staff.

As well as the general discussion page here you can also enter comments under other topics – such as the lead page on Human Rights.

Atheist Ireland believes that a secular education system is essential to the building of an ethical and secular society. One of the most powerful ways in which religion maintains its hold on society is by teaching children fantastic tales as truth when they are at an intellectually formative age.

Atheist Ireland is an advocacy group that promotes reason and atheism over superstition and supernaturalism, and that campaigns for an ethical and secular Ireland where the state does not support or fund or give special treatment to any religion.

 

 

10 Comments

  1. Avatar
    Sinead November 09, 2011

    I absolutely do not agree the death-grip the church has on the Irish Education System but I’m not sure I agree with secular education either.
    France have an excellent model, but one must wonder if links can be drawn between their ignorance of religious faiths and the social divides due to the break down of integration.
    I do not a follow a religion but was educated in Catholic schools. 25 years later, I have very limited knowledge the core beliefs of Islam, Judaism, Hinduism… any religion in fact.
    Would our children be better served by being equipped with an understanding of all the major world religions instead of being bombarded with Catholicism or being deprived of the of religious education all together?
    Is pushing for a secular model counter productive? Would we be replacing one totalitarian system with another?

    Reply
    • Avatar
      Paul April 03, 2012

      > Would we be replacing one totalitarian system with another?

      I don’t think this fear is grounded.

      With secular education every parent is free to educate their own children in whatever religion they choose or, none at all. This education can happen at home or at weekends (Sunday school etc).

      However, once standard, compulsory education contains religious indoctrination parents cannot ‘remove’ this indoctrination from the child after school. (Sunday de-programming school?).

      So, Secular Schooling removes the totalitarian system and replaces it with choice.

      Reply
      • Avatar
        Gavin July 09, 2012

        May I ask why people who advocate secular education never seem to give any backing to the idea of funding all schools equally regardless of whether they have a faith based ethos or not. Would the funding of all schools equally not be more egalitarian than saying that only schools with a secular ethos should receive public funding. Why should those who are sincerely Muslim, Christian,Jewish etc. not be able to attend an institution that serves them rather than having to attend religious education only at weekends, as is often proposed. It seems that those who favour secular education are attempting to control the choices that religious people can make as regards education, by making secular education the only choice. If those who want secular education receive public funding is it not only right an fair that those who want a faith based education get the same amount?

        Reply
  2. Avatar
    Heather Smith April 22, 2012

    I have taught in a Protestant school for over thirty years and I have always taught about world religions. I strongly recommend that you read the “Follow Me” programme for the senior classes. I think you would enjoy it.

    Reply
    • Avatar
      Suzanne July 31, 2015

      The “Follow Me” Programme
      “I hope that teachers will both enjoy this programme and also find it useful and effective in the task of bringing our children to a greater knowledge and love of the Lord Jesus Christ.”
      I don’t think this is at all appropriate for any non religious child to be honest.

      Reply
  3. Avatar
    Clare Mum September 18, 2012

    My husband and I spoke to the principal of my sons Secondary School today .We explained that we are atheists and that our son is an atheist and therefore he would like to opt out of religious education .The principal, whom we had only met by chance (we had no appointment)said that it would not be possible to opt out ,I mentioned our constitutional right and he had to run off to more immediate commitments.It was so good to find your page and to discover the help at hand,thanks.

    Reply
    • Avatar
      Jane Donnelly September 18, 2012

      We will give you any help that we can. You might be interested to read the Report from the Irish Human Rights Commission called Religion & Education: A Human Rights Perspective. On page 26 – para 62 it states the following:- “It is noted, however, that the Junior Certificate Religious Education Syllabus is an optional subject for the Junior Certificate examination. At individual school level it may be possible to make the subject compulsory but this does not override the right of students to be exempted from such instruction in accordance with the Education Act.” We are getting a lot of complaints from parents claiming that schools are refusing to let them opt out of religion. As you can see schools have absolutely no right to refuse.
      http://www.ihrc.ie/publications/list/religion-and-education-a-human-rights-perspective/

      Reply
  4. Avatar
    Clare Mum September 23, 2012

    Thanks Jane,this clarifies a lot for me.I have spoken to my son and he has now decided to continue with classes in religion and to opt out of homework and any study.As a sixteen year old boy he is very sure of what he believes and does not believe but hates any focus on him and feels that because everyone else in his school has to do religion he has to too.For me that is the sorriest part of all this is that he wasn’t asked, as a person with rights he should have been asked if he would like to do religious studies or not.I would love to send a letter to the Headmaster as I feel we are really getting somewhere on lots of issues pertaining to catholicism and the more parents who opt out the more normal it will become and before we know it everyone will understand their rights and more importantly the rights of others.My two boys 16 and 18 have just finished reading Dawkins ‘the god delusion’,they are streets ahead of my husband and I and therein lies our future ,…………… with tongue firmly in cheek…’Praise the Lord’,great to be having this discussion,THANKS.

    Reply
  5. Avatar
    june October 02, 2012

    In relation to Paul and Sinead’s points I might just briefly mention that it seems there is some confusion between religious instruction and religious education.
    Sunday Schools, for example, would provide the instruction side of things while schools, if they were to provide a full and thorough education, should provide religious education.
    Let’s not forget that education is for the benefit of the child, it should prepair the child for the world and, like it or lump it, a large population follows one religion or another (or none, of course).
    No one religion should be given partrticular attention and children should have, at the very least, a familiarity with the major religions.
    In my view, a full education should include world religions so that pluralism, integration and interculturalism is promoted.
    Everyone has the right to hold and express their own individual beliefs but they should too be aware that their religion, or lack of, is not the only belief nor is it a superior one.

    Reply
  6. Avatar
    Jane Donnelly October 04, 2012

    For most secular parents there is no issue with their children learning ABOUT religions and beliefs. If we look at this from a human rights perspective then this teaching must be delivered in an objective, critical and pluralistic manner. There are agreed human rights principles on how this type of Religious Education/ Ethics course must be delivered. These are called the Toledo Guiding Principles.
    The problem in Ireland is that the Catholic Church has rejected these principles. The Religious Education course at second level is not delivered in an objective, critical and pluralistic manner because the Catholic Church does not accept basic human rights principles.
    So despite the state claiming that the RE Course at second level is for all religions and none it is not based on human rights principles. As you can well imagine the Catholic Church and indeed all other religions were consulted when they drew up this course. I have been informed that the Humanist Assoc of Ireland objected to the course but their objections were disregarded.
    Atheist Ireland has complained to the Minister for Education and the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment regarding this course but of course we were ignored. The NCCA have stated in a letter to us that they have no control over how the RE Course is delivered. This means that if your child attends a school with a religious ethos then the RE course will be delivered according to that ethos. In most cases that is the Catholic Church. Denominational schools, VEC Community Schools and VEC designated Community Colleges all operate with a religious ethos. I would not even trust the non-designated Community colleges. In essence then it is Religious Education according to the Catholic Church. This education does not constitute respect under human rights law.
    I am providing a link below to a Circular Letter from the Vatican on Religious Education in schools. This will give you an idea of the problems with any RE course in Ireland.
    The Forum on Patronage and Pluralism has recommended that a new course for Primary Level called Education about Religion and Beliefs be introduced and based on the Toledo Guiding Principles. The Catholic Church will object to that and we will see how far it gets then.
    http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/ccatheduc/documents/rc_con_ccatheduc_doc_20090505_circ-insegn-relig_en.html

    Reply

Leave reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *