Report: Atheist, Evangelical and Ahmadiyya Muslim alliance meets Council of Europe Commissioner about secular schools
Today a unique secular alliance met Nils Muižnieks, the Council of Europe’s Commissioner for Human Rights, to discuss children’s rights in Irish publicly funded national schools. Jane Donnelly told Commissioner Muižnieks that she was proud to speak on behalf of Atheist Ireland, Evangelical Alliance Ireland, and the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community of Ireland.
“We are three groups with very different world views,” she said, “but we are agreed on one thing: the Irish State should stop discriminating on the ground of religion, particularly in our schools.” Jane and Michael Nugent also gave the Council of Europe Commissioner a written report that includes perspectives from the three different belief groups.
Afterwards Jane and Michael met with Paul Rowe, the CEO of Educate Together, to discuss the overall issue of how to end religious discrimination in Irish schools. They will also attend a wider meeting on Friday, which Commissioner Muižnieks will be addressing, along with Pastor Nick Park of Evangelical Alliance Ireland, and Imam Ibrahim Noonan of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community of Ireland.
Irish State fails to protect human rights
At the meeting with Commissioner Muižnieks, Jane explained that the Irish State does not protect the human rights guaranteed under the European Convention.
“If we want our children to attend their only local state-funded school, that school can give preference to Catholics, at both primary and second level. But that is only a small part of the problem. Even we could get fair admission policies, we would only be getting our children access to a school in which they would be subjected to religious discrimination throughout the entire school day. This is because the Irish State does not require that the State Curriculum is delivered in an objective, critical and pluralistic manner, which would be consistent with human rights standards.”
Jane also told Commissioner Muižnieks exactly how the State breaches these human rights.
“To begin, the Irish State cedes control of our publicly funded schools to private Patrons, the vast majority of whom are Catholic Bishops. The State then gives those Bishops exemptions from our equality laws, to allow them to discriminate on the ground of religion against children, parents and teachers. The State further argues that it is constitutionally obliged — not merely permitted, but obliged — to buttress this religious discrimination. We are not talking about faith schools as alternatives to the State system. They are the State system. And most parents have no alternative.”
Children cannot opt out from school ethos
Jane explained that parents who are Atheist, Evangelical, Ahmadiyya Muslim, or of other minority faiths, can legally opt their children out of the formal Religious Instruction classes. But the schools don’t provide alternative classes, so their children have to sit at the back of the religion class they are supposed to be opted out of.
But more importantly, the Catholic ethos is integrated throughout the State Curriculum and the entire school day.
- will go to school wearing Catholic symbols on their compulsory school uniforms,
- might have to pray at the beginning of classes
- will sit in a classroom with a Catholic prayer table,
- will get Catholic Relationship and Sexuality Education,
- will learn hymns in music and draw crucifixes in art,
- will even learn sentences in English class like ‘We should believe what we read in the Bible.’
- will be taken to church during Holy Communion preparation
- will come home reciting prayers even though they are opted out of religion class.
Children cannot opt out of this religious ethos. This breaches the positive obligation on the State to respect the human right of parents to ensure that the teaching of their children is in conformity with their convictions. This right to respect is an absolute right, not to be balanced against the rights of others, or one that can be gradually achieved.
The Patronage system itself is the problem
During the discussion with Commissioner Muižnieks, Jane and Michael elaborated on the need to replace the school patronage system itself. They said that the Oireachtas Education Committee has already concluded that multiple patronage and multiple ethos of schools can lead to segregation and inequality. We need a religiously neutral State school system, instead of making the system even more segregated by adding more private patrons each with their own religious ethos.
They explained that, even if the State provided the 400 multi-denominational schools that it is promising fifteen years from now, that would still be a small proportion of the more than three thousand primary schools with a religious ethos. And the Catholic Church is trying to negotiate that, in return for divestment of some schools, it should have a stronger Catholic ethos in the majority of schools that it retains. That would leave most atheist and minority faith parents in an even worse position than they are now.
They said that the failure to protect Convention rights was obvious in the Louise O’Keeffe case at the European Court. The Irish State had failed to ensure protection for children under Article 3, and the Court also found that there was no effective remedy to vindicate Convention Rights under Article 13. The same principles apply to the rights guaranteed under Article II of Protocol 1 of the European Convention, and under Articles 8, 9, 10 and 14. Despite this, the Irish State still cedes control of the education system to private Patron bodies, mainly religious ones.
Finally Jane and Michael explained that, while they continue to campaign for a secular school system, the alliance supports the immediate implementation of the Recommendations from the Irish Human Rights & Equality Commission on the Admission to Schools Bill 2016, including amendment of Section 7–3(c) of the Equal Status Act, and Section 15–2(b) of The Education Act.
Pictured above: afterwards Jane and Michael met with Paul Rowe, the CEO of Educate Together, to discuss the overall issue of how to end religious discrimination in Irish schools.